Sanjaya Malakar is still safe, Brandon says goodbye

Three American Idol Finalists were called to the center of the stage. They belonged to the bottom three.

First to be called was:


photocredits:americanidol.com

1. Brandon Rogers, 28, North Hollywood, Calif.


Song: You Can't Hurry Love

Judges' ratings :
Randy: Boring
Paula: There are things which are right
Simon: You forgot the words/No originality

Second in the list was :

Phil Stacey,29, Jacksonville, Fla.

Song: I'm Gonna Make You Love Me

Judges' ratings :

Randy: Hot vocal
Paula: Good vocal
Simon: It wasn't awful/it was good.

Third was Sanjaya Malakar, 17, Federal Way, Wash.



Song: Ain't No Mountain High Enough

Judges' ratings :
Randy: It was not good.But th hair is good.
Paula: You got to explode your voice.
Simon Cowell: You are very brave.


American Idol Results,
Simon Cowell,Randy Jackson,Paula Abdul,karaoke,Ryan Seacrest,Barba,AJ Tabaldo,Lakisha Jones,Jordin Sparks,
Gina Glocksen,Sundance Head,Sabrina Sloan,Jared Cotter,Sanjaya Malakar,
Chris Richardson, Blake Lewis,Chris Sligh, Phil Stacey,Brandon +Rogers,Haley Scarnato, Stephanie Edwards,Melinda Doolittle,Sanjaya Malakar